Patrick Mahomes is clearly feeling the impact of losing his third Super Bowl in a row. The Eagles’ defense effectively neutralized Mahomes, putting forth a performance that shifted him from a once-extraordinary realm into the realm of ordinary quarterbacks—something that some skeptics have begun to suggest he may be. The kind of criticism he faces echoes the narrative surrounding NBA star LeBron James—but this time, it’s not a positive comparison.
Much like LeBron, Mahomes has achieved multiple championships and built a resume likely to earn him Hall of Fame recognition. Yet, for both, the elusive title of the greatest of all time (GOAT) remains out of reach. Instead, there’s a new label gaining momentum: “overrated.” This tag has particularly resonated with disgruntled football fans eager to criticize rather than celebrate accomplishments.
On The Coach JB Show, hosts Jason Brown and Rob Parker leveled serious accusations at Mahomes, branding him as drastically overrated and drawing parallels to New York Giants quarterback Daniel Jones, known for his inconsistent performances. Their critique doesn’t hold back, challenging the authenticity of Mahomes’ acclaim.
Coach JB explicitly stated, “The guy’s overrated as sh*t. He is one of the most overrated superstars in the history of professional sports, right alongside LeBron. We see him throwing flashy, no-look passes, making it seem like he’s redefining quarterback play. But when you dig deeper, it’s apparent he’s not encountering the pressures that other QBs face.” He argues that true quarterback skills involve consistency in execution—something he believes Mahomes currently lacks.
Rob Parker added to the discussion by highlighting the surprising similarities in statistics between Mahomes and Jones. He opines that fans’ frustrations stem from Mahomes’ three Super Bowl victories, suggesting that this achievement is more attributable to teamwork than individual excellence.
Parker repeatedly emphasizes that Mahomes appears to be riding on his past laurels instead of current performances, which he believes lack the same prowess they once had. He cites Super Bowl 59 as a perfect example of this biased perception, where Mahomes was expected to shine due to his reputation.
“People were upset with me when I said he’s turned into Daniel Jones stat-wise, but for some reason, fans can’t see it,” Parker remarked. “How does a team that goes 15-2 not have a quarterback receiving a single first-place MVP vote? How can that even happen?”
Despite the Eagles demonstrating a more robust lineup, the Chiefs were still favored, largely because of Mahomes. Parker, who confidently predicted the Eagles’ victory, found it perplexing how much faith people continued to place in Mahomes, especially given that he hasn’t played at an elite level for quite some time.
Even MVP voters took notice of Mahomes’ this season, with the quarterback not receiving a single first-place vote—a shocking detail considering he led a team with a stellar 15-2 record, a statistic that typically earns at least a mention in MVP discussions.
Mahomes’ statistics have started to resemble those of seasoned quarterbacks like Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson, both of whom have faced significant criticism this season for their subpar performances. In stark contrast, Mahomes seems to enjoy a degree of unexamined support, raising further questions. Although there’s growing acknowledgment of his decline, many individuals continue to overlook it.
Labeling a two-time MVP as “overrated” seems misguided at best. You don’t win three Lombardi Trophies and two MVP awards purely by chance. While it’s true that Mahomes’ numbers and the surrounding excitement have fluctuated, this should not be seen as a mere decline in talent; rather, it reflects an evolution in his game, adapting to his team’s current needs instead of regressing.
It’s important to acknowledge that the Chiefs have faced their own struggles, particularly in crucial areas such as their offensive line and receiving corps. No quarterback, regardless of how talented, can succeed without the necessary support. After all, even Tom Brady had strong teams backing him. Football is a team sport; Mahomes alone cannot shoulder the burden of an entire team.
While it may be reasonable to debate Mahomes’ status as a GOAT given recent events, labeling him as “overrated” at this juncture might be premature. There’s much more to his journey and the challenges he faces, and perhaps it’s time for a more nuanced understanding of what defines greatness in a quarterback.
